If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. Sodium Methyl 2-Sulfolaurate a coconut derived readily biodegradable gentle surfactant with viscosity modifying characteristics from coconut Another really gentle surfactant, Coconut Acid a coconut derived gentle cleanser and emulsifier, Amylase Enzyme Blend removes starch stains and helps surfactant ingredients clean even better, Mannanase Enzyme Blend removes organic stains and helps the detergent ingredients clean even better, Lipase Enzyme Blend removes fat and oil stains and helps the detergent ingredients clean even better, Citrus Limon (Lemon) Peel Oil provides fragrance, Abies Alba (Fir) Leaf Oil provides fragrance and cleaning efficacy, Cymbopogon Schoenanthus (Lemongrass) Oil provides fragrance and reduces foaming, Methylisothiazolinone while this is a non-formaldehyde preservative which ther company proudly claim, this preservative. The next group of not-great ingredients includes ethoxylated ones. There were a few contenders on the table, including both nationally known and local companies. Replies to my comments
youre polluting the earth with more plastic than gets recycled. ~Irina. Nonetheless, in my opinion, it should have a higher rating for the following reasons. I actually love the smell of this stuff, but it seems to be causing an allergic reaction on my hands. Uhhhh!!! The mixture I made of ACv & water smells moldy. Its this balance that we hope to achieve with the products we make. Back to vinegar, water, and essential oils for me! Any thoughts on whether these essential oils are safe? - so wash up right away. Best of luck with your domestic endeavors! Now I am searching for alternative products that are all natural for household and skincare. I have also had reactions to certain natural cosmetics. I dont know about you, but I like to know whats in the stuff Im washing my hands with or spraying on my kitchen countertop. Mrs. Meyers has since corrected this problem. Because it is the second on the ingredient list, its amount is quite high. And I did start my own cleaning product company! Lavender seems the closest; I know they use essential oils in that one. This post also describes some ways to use Branch Basics around your home with peace of mind regarding its safety. Overall, Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day Dish Soap smells absolutely amazing and cleans very well too. The first change in Mrs. Meyers products as I mentioned above is the disclosure of their fragrance ingredients and warning us that there are allergens among them. Thus,its not one of those companies where you can say that all the products are toxic, or all are safe. Have you tried doTERRA Essential Oils products made from PURE essential oils? Thanks for adding to the discussion. Your email address will not be published. That is good news. I am currently home sick because of a strong alleric reaction I had to Mrs. Meyers Basil countertop spray, which I used three days ago. And many of them (Mrs. Meyers included) are owned by huge corporations that cant always be trusted when it comes to things like ingredient sourcing and transparency. I have found a company whose products I love..Better Life (http://cleanhappens.com). Please try Ava Anderson Non Toxic products!! Hi Amanda! Why on earth do I need to pay for this in yet another plastic, packaged commodity? I do like the direction that Eco-Me products are going baking soda, and white vinegar ingredients BUT as a consumer why are we paying for these formulations at all? In their assessment, Mrs. Meyers products range from 3 to 6 on their 10-point hazard scale (thats moderately hazardous). I dont generally have allergy symptoms or use fabric softener. I do not take companies safety claims at face value. I did not know she had even bought this product and was using it when I got a whiff of some strange smell that immediately gave me a pounding headache. I love all the products I have tried from them, but the hand soaps have been a daily game-changer for me. This particular bottle is the lemon verbena scented. Version theresa multitude of options available. I wish I had checked before I wasted my money. Stay tuned for part 2 of why I think Mrs. Meyers stinks: synthetic fragrance-free solutions! How can we trust they arent going to make concessions to ingredient safety or sourcing to get a bigger bottom line? I got this hand soap thinking it was only scented with essential oils. Ingredients like polyethylene glycol (PEG), and many more ingredients with eth in the name fall under this category. The geranium instantly gave me a headache, so I started researching if it is in fact all natural wish i would have found this site 2 days agoor researched before I bought. Recyclable Packaging* (less pumps & caps) >> Im personally not too impressed by recyclability anymore. Floor cleaner (for mopping, we typically use Swiffer, not sure if they have healthy, friendly options) My kids also have sensitive skin which complicates matters even more. How I missed the fragrance ingredient while at the store I have no idea. I mean I enjoy yummy smelling and new products too, but I have a messy man 2messy kids, and pets. The ingredients I would like to draw your attention to are fragrance and preservatives. Thank you. I prefer the basic Palmolive dish detergent. I dont think its fragrance, its what fragrance cover. D. Countertop Cleaner (7) Score Range: D. Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day Basil Countertop Spray. Additionally, if a label describes its ingredients as naturally-derived, it can be rather misleading. Its still the same issue with this brand of dish soap and products. Mrs. Meyers Products Are Free From Some of the Worst Ingredients, 3. I tried many different soaps but was using Mrs. Meyers for a long time. Think about that for a moment. The greatest distinction here is this: It is not a synthetic cleaning product making false claims of being safe or environmentally friendly. A lot of people on their Facebook Page seem equally displeased. Bathroom cleaner The only product they dont have available on their website (which is CleanHappens which was confusing for me to find) is a Laundry detergentDoes someone have a good recommendation on a great all natural laundry detergent that ACTUALLY CLEANS!?!? Is Mrs. Meyers Vegan and/or Cruelty-Free? Concentrated Formula includes Soap bark Extract, one of Nature's Best Degreasers. Hi, Claudene: Thank you for asking! Did you ever end up finding one? I had to find blankets and pillows that werent washed in that and sleep in a different room with them. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Laureth-7 a plant-derived, very gentle nonionic cleaning ingredient. I have always used Baking Soda, White Vinegar, etc., sooooooo I guess I will stick to the SAFE ingredients that are available. I asked her what she was using to wash the dishes and she handed me the basil scented Meyers dishwashing soap, the stuff had the most vile chemical laden smell for a supposedly natural product. I too, make homemade cleaning solutions using vinegar, water, essential oils, baking soda etc. Eco-Me brings a fun and fresh new energy to the cleaning category with its back-to-basics ingredients and modern family branding. Our fragrance compositions use a combination of natural essential oils and safe synthetic ingredients. Thank you! Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS). They do make two scents, Rosemary and Bluebell, that do not contain synthetic fragrance though. But it is not. They use pure organic essential oils & fair trade ingredients. the new old home of raganella's botanical solutions, announcing my new body care & cleaningCSA, synthetic fragrance-free solutions (part 2 of why i think mrs. meyersstinks), Get a Whiff of This: Perfumes (fragrances) the Invisible Chemical Poisons, a study where Mrs. Meyers was found to contain high levels of 1,4 dioxane, synthetic fragrance-free solutions (part 2 of why i think mrs. meyers stinks), Products that promote themselves as natural but contain artificial fragrance | Fragrance Stinks, http://www.avaandersonnontoxic.com/patricia, Mrs. Meyers Lemon Verbena My Fragrance-Sensitive Life, Everyday Activism: Little Effort, Big Results | Newzsentinel. . (+ A Review). They cut through grease, remove stuck-on grime, and generally do what they need to do. Multipurpose cleaner Again, its really hard to avoid these ingredients completely, but it can be a good idea to try and minimize exposure to them when you can. I did some googling, and found this: Why I think Mrs. Meyers Stinks Im not the only one who has a reaction to Mrs. []. We should always wear gloves nonetheless. Ive never had dry skin before the day I used it Ive always had very fair skin, but also very soft. Then, lauryl alcohol is treated with sulfur trioxide gas or chlorosulfuric acid to produce Sodium Lauryl Sulfate. ~Irina, Hi there. Ive always suspected Mrs. Meyers soaps included artificial fragrance because a) the scent on my hands did not go away quicklyb) I could taste the scent through my nose, c) the scent made me nauseated. This site contains affiliate links, which means we may earn a commission if you choose to make a purchase. The results were very good indeed. Add to Bucket. Read about the founders moving story as to why she started Eco-Me here: http://www.eco-me.com/pages/ourstory. Check out my research into glucosides to make your own decision about their safety. The ratings indicate the relative level of concern posed by exposure to the ingredients in this product - not the product itself - compared to other product formulations. I totally agree!!! I am especially fond of these non-toxic cleaners that wont break the bank and give you peace of mind. CAUTION: Avoid eye contact. Just because something is inspired by nature doesnt actually mean it comes from nature or is good for nature. While in the privy of one of my favorite restaurants (lots of local & sustainable NYC restaurants love Mrs. Meyers), I decided to peek at the label to confirm my suspicions. This means those with eczema or other skin sensitivities should probably stay away from Mrs. Meyers products. I was itchy red breaking out all over itchy throat coughing started choking had a hard time breathing I took benadryl and it helped before any swelling happened but worst allergic reaction Ive experienced so far to anything, Hi, Niki: I am so sorry to hear that. Are Mrs. Meyers Cleaning Products Actually Non-Toxic? There are some really well-chosen ingredients in here. So regarding the article I read about Mrs. Meyers Clean Day hand soapI too am using cute liquid soap dispensers in my home and want to find large refills of a safe soap. Thank you so much for this article! I also used the spray in a shower stall and it affected my eyes, head, and lungs. CP, Hi, Chrissy, be sure to check out my Shop: https://ireadlabelsforyou.com/shop/ ~Irina. I really wish you wouldnt paint them as all bad. My husband cleaned the bathroom sink with Meyers hand soap. Learn how your comment data is processed. Nonetheless, in my opinion, it should have a higher rating for the following reasons. Well, it did a great miracle and my skin was healing. On the face of it, Mrs. Meyers represents a new breed of cleaning product manufacturer who are slowly emerging. I actually recently came to the same conclusion. On the lower end are detergents that cost just $.10 per load. Thanks for calling this company out onto the carpet. Oh, and some kind of natural dryer sheets. You can read more about the fragrance loophole right here. Hi, there! And plenty of synthetic are completely harmless. Some people saying the products must be synthetic and toxic because of the allergic responses they had. Your email address will not be published. NO TOXIC CHEMICALS!!!! Even though Im fully conscious of the fact that these sort of made without claims do not automatically mean a product is totally non-toxic, Im still generally glad to see them. Back in 2009, Caldrea (who makes Mrs. Meyers) got sued for violating the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act (Proposition 65). , Hi, Patsy! Hi! Well, I see now my Mrs. Meyers is no good and have not used it, but here is my issue. I am here looking it up from Google. You can see them in processed non-organic food. (Well answer that question in a minute!). The other two surfactants in the Mrs. Meyers hand soap are Sodium Methyl 2-Sulfolaurate and Disodium 2-Sulfolaurate. These people are irresponsible and are marketing what I believe is a substance completely unsuitable for the intended use. S.C. Johnson as well as several of the brands it owns has gotten in trouble in the past for things like toxic ingredients in its products, testing on animals, and greenwashing. Additionally, whether or not something is truly recyclable often depends on where its being recycled and what that citys capabilities are, so putting a blanket recyclable statement over something isnt really that helpful. Well, true I guess. Some isothiazolinone preservatives are also suspected to be endocrine disrupting as well. I hope the day will come when Mrs. Meyers products will include unscented versions. Mrs. Meyers cleaning products do not have an organic certification, so they are not organic. Thank you so much for your blog! Additionally, as mentioned above, its parent company, S. C. Johnson, has faced various lawsuits over the years. D. Mrs. Meyer's Clean Day Honeysuckle Countertop Spray. Hello! As for the other fragrance ingredients, even though their rating is 1 (with 10 as most toxic), they have limited safety data as indicated in the EWG Skin Deep database. I'm on a mission to help you make informed and practical decisions about products you buy. if any. It might smell good but I am convinced it is as poisonous as anything else on the market. Then add vinegar. ; [Fragrance: (Coumarin, Geraniol, Limonene, Linalool); Lavandula Angustifolia (Lavender) Oil ; Citrus Aurantium Dulcis (Orange) Peel Oil ; Linalool; Geraniol; Geranyl Acetate; Coumarin; Phenethyl Alcohol; P-Methoxybenzyl Acetate; Hexyl Salicylate; Camphor; Pinene; Limonene; Lavandula Hybrida Oil; Dipropylene Glycol; Linalyl Acetate; Limonene; Pinus Palustris Oil; Eucalyptol]; Sodium Citrate; Subtilisins (Protease) Enzyme Blend; Amylase Enzyme Blend; Mannanase Enzyme Blend; Lipase Enzyme Blend; Tetrasodium Glutamate Diacetate; Glycerin; Calcium Chloride; Sodium Chloride; Sodium Sulfate; Potassium Hydroxide; Methylisothiazolinone; Benzisothiazolinone (source). Thus, if you are looking for an organic laundry detergent, head to my post about two certified organic brands. Thank you so much for this post, I have to take more time to read in detail, but right now I am going to change my soap IMMEDIATELY!!! I sprayed some in the sink & squirted a little on the floor to do around the base of the toilet. Mrs. meyers products are NOT SAFE, and what is with all of the tree oils in the ingredients? Finally I dumped the entire container down the toilet and begged my significant other to run buy some decent detergent. All of the information by those ahead of me here have been very helpful. Other products claiming to contain essential oils are just the scent of oils which always includes synthetic ingredients that can cause irritation like you mentioned. Needless to say I contacted the company and they did a lot of beating around the bush in explaining their safe synthetic fragrance. This debate is vital to the integrity of any consumer product and its commitment to full disclosure. Thank you! I would love to help you! Synthetic fragrances are toxic. Does anyone have anything to say regarding pure selects its fragrance free but does offer fragrances that you can insert. Have you ever done any reviews on Amway or Shaklee cleaning products? I just started trying Mrs. Meyers cleaners this past year and I hate the way it smells and the way the smell stays around for days. Hey Irina, I suggest you always take claims made by a brand with a grain of salt. Toilet bowl cleaner They are truly natural, not synthetic. We are sorry to hear that! This is probably the most common excuse companies give for not disclosing ingredient information to their customers. I was covered in big welts where I touched it. Made with Essential Oils & Other Thoughtfully Chosen / Plant-Derived Ingredients >> Even though its made with essential oils, that doesnt mean there arent other (potentially problematic) ingredients added. Im curious if you have an article breaking down the brand Ever Spring as well? Are these just another excuse to buy yet another consumer product to clutter the kitchen cupboards? In addition, there are three essential oils: If this was the crux of the formulation Id have been singing its praises from the rooftops. If you dive into the various product labels, youll find that Mrs. Meyers discloses some of their fragrance ingredients, while continuing to hide others. This means they do not kill germs, but rather, lower the number of germs by wiping them away (along with other bacteria, dirt, etc.). In conclusion, I believe Mrs. Meyers hand soap is not bad. I was fine as soon as I got on in the new bedding. it becomes evident in how you express yourself, and that it is a part of Your fire. Its been ten minutes and my throat and lungs still hurt. I will say that many of Ms. Meyers bottles say theyre Made with at least 30% post-consumer plastic. And while thats certainly better than nothing when it comes to reducing the amount of virgin plastic being generated, there are many other things Mrs. Meyers could do to decrease the amount of plastic in their products (like offer refill or concentrate options, employ compostable paper parts, etc). After a brief look into the Grove Collaborative, I can tell you that not all their products meet my safety requirements. In my post about the safety of cocamidopropyl hydroxysultaine, you can learn about the chemical used to produce this ingredient, and also why it is considered a sensitizer. However, I believe that they are much safer than methylisothiazolinone and benzisothiazolinone. EWG is in the process of updating this score. Wondering if you have any recommendations on the following: Now that I am reading this post and the comments it all makes more sense. I just wish vinegar came in a powder form and sold in a box no plastics for me! []. I dont know what it is, but I will NEVER use that product again! Natural is a relative term. Id rather focus on solutions than problems. Aloe Vera. To begin, the term natural has no legal definition, and, thus, its meaning may differ depending on the context. In addition to some concerning fragrance ingredients mentioned above, there is Hexyl Cinnamal. I appreciate your article because it points out some questionable ingredients but also says that its one of the better ones out there considering there are very harmful products in the shelves. Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. Every area of my skin, where I used the body wash, became dry, irritated and tight. I usually only have natural and safe products in my home. ), A Brief Overview of the Mrs. Meyers Brand. Its not really about slamming products as it is about educating the world. In fact, they are on my approved list of preservatives. Thank you for asking. Enjoy! But you have to use foaming dispensers with it; otherwise, it is too thin. Is Mrs. Meyers Really Safe? Please think also of all the extra energy requirements of liquid soaps you are essentially moving water around just so you can use a dispenser and perhaps save a little mess. I originally bought the countertop spray with the thought of, use a natural product now, and when its empty I have a great spray bottle to use for my DIY cleaner. Never ever have I had a reaction like this to anything in the world and Im almost 40! http://www.avaandersonnontoxic.com/patricia or on FB as ava anderson non toxic presented by patricia, Hey i just bought lavendar laundry soap and my comforter of 5 yrs and new sheets i just washed lost its sheen im beyond upset no more sheen on my satin comforter and it feels scratchy and itchy now ,great dont mind if i lose money on soap but now my beautiful comforter is ruined, i will go to vinegar and maybe dreft baby detergent so its easy on clothes i guess, READERS BEWARE: Before you go tossing out your Mrs. Meyers cleaners, please be advised that this blog is written by a person who sells herbal drugs on Etsy called vivid visions.. Your blog is great! Do you have a preference for an essential oil company ? I used to buy them at Whole foods thinking since they are sold there- they must be totally all natural. A few user reviews: As I mentioned, I like to use my senses. Life begins to smell (naturally) sweet again. Thanks for your feedback, Alison. Lets give an answer to it. It smells like musk. I keep hearing great things about Better Life. In the middle, you'll find detergent packs that cost $.17 a load. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Bad stuff in the scent! Please that that into account. Although its a step in the right direction its only half way there and since its a little more expensive to buy I would like to know I am purchasing a completely natural product. Ive used Lysol and from time to time did not wear gloves, and my skin was fine..dont try this out. When possible, EWG's Guide rates all available versions. Methylisothiazolinone. Thank you so much for writing this. Ive never purchased mrs Meyers, but when I was a home health aide I came across some of these products in peoples homes. Your comment will definitely help someone else. Low and behold there it wasFRAGRANCE! Mostly bodycare and make up. My all time favorite is Dr. Bronners liquid soap. But from a green perspective are they really that bad? Mrs. Meyers please cut out the synthetics- and I will try you again. (LogOut/ Does anyone else find these titles, for example of these plant essential oils silly? I only use Dawn dish detergent on my dishes and I use it for cleaning, but not hand washing. Ethoxylation is a part of the manufacturing process. PURE ingredients that wont harm our families and pets, waterways, the environment or our homes. On their website, Mrs. Meyers states that Our products never contain ammonia, chlorine, parabens, phthalates, formaldehyde, artificial colorants, phosphates or petroleum distillates.. I came across this looking for what happened to the radish scent that I love, I found out its discontinued. Copyright 2023, The Filtery. The Best Eco Friendly Dishwasher Detergents, The Best Green Dish Soaps, Dish Washing Soaps and Washing Up Liquids, Review :: ECOS Free & Clear Laundry Detergent, Lauryl Glucoside a mild sugar derived gentle surfactant. Dont bother thank you very much! All fragrances are phthalate-free.. All viewers of this content, especially those taking prescription or over-the-counter medications, should consult their physicians before beginning any nutrition, supplement, or lifestyle program. All reviews are independent and any products reviewed are purchased by the site owner. It is rated 1 (with 10 as most toxic) and has limited data in theEWG Skin Deep database. The European Unions Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) considers benzisothiazolinone safe for use as a preservative in cosmetics products up to 0.01% with respect to systemic toxicity. Its stocked throughout the home cleaning aisles at big box stores like Target and Walmart. I would love them to stock boxes of A&H washing soda and 64 oz size of Dr Bonners and other simple, hard to get staples. On a scale of 1 to 5, I gave the smell about a 3. They understand the impact their products have and have formulated them accordingly. I could not get the smell off my hands and it thus followed me everywhere, continuing to irritate my respiratory system. $8.39. NO FRAGRANCE!!!! Mrs. Meyers soaps form a rash on the backs of my hands. Not okay Mrs. Meyers. It is sad that some people cannot accept the truth. ~Irina. You might be right, Maddie! Said friend asked me to offer some advice on choosing an eco-friendly house cleaning service. Thank you! As consumers, we do not know if there is any residue left in the products we use. After washing and drying a load I noticed the clothes did look cleaner, slightly brighter. Thanks! HOUSEHOLD HINT Before washing your dishes, scrape off food. Only a small fraction of plastics get recycled anyway (even if the consumer actually puts it in the proper bin in the right way). Ive smelled the mrs Meyers hand soaps at Walmart out of curiosity and I really didnt care for any of the scents, some were downright nasty. Besides, there is an ethoxylated ingredient in this laundry detergent. Once I bought on of the products (s spray cleaners) and after one use I poured it down the drain with one hand while holding my nose with the other. Not to mention, most of its ingredient lists are really long and difficult for the average consumer to decipher. In the end, Mrs. Meyers had to pay $50,000 and bring the levels of 1,4 dioxane in their dish soap to below that limit. I have been looking into young living essential oils and their cleaning products. A part of me wonders if there is some kind of genetic factor when it comes to Mrs. Meyers. Feel free to use the main menu at the top of my website pages to navigate my website. This product boasts it has no parabens, phthalates, phosphate, chlorine or formaldehyde. But what's the difference between the two, and how do you know which one is best for you? However, its can be contaminated with 1,4-dioxane depending on how its manufactured. I do have a website where these products can be purchased. By the way, the absence of preservatives in a product is concerning too and sometimes even dangerous. I looked at the bottle again today because my clothes were smelling unusually good ,as if I had gone back to my Downey days. Im really curious to know what the common ingredient is so I can avoid it in the future. that were trying to clean up. Im not done bitching, just completed an FDA complaint form. Just read that South Texas (where I live) has hard water so confirms your suspicions. Moreover, the American Contact Dermatitis Society named this ingredient Contact Allergen of the Year for 2013. We are glad we can help! When comparing the price of laundry detergent, you'll need to divide the cost by the number of loads. I am very very sensitive to the synthetic chemicals fragrances and such. I have used Mrs. Meyers products in the past, and I can say that, yes, they are just as effective as other cleaners (both conventional and non-toxic) when it comes to getting the job done. So, I think the Olive Oil ingredient does nothing, and you need to decrease the quantity of the concenrate chemicals/ingredients. May also have poor ingredient disclosure. Where is your attach photo option?!?! Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Well look at things like ingredient transparency, their use of safe (or unsafe) ingredients, and the pros and cons of the brand as a whole. Eco-Me was born out of need and concern. (This cant be said for many other personal care and cleaning brands, especially the larger and more conventional ones.) Thanks for keeping us posted, Lynn! ~Irina. The next group of problematic ingredients includes Benzisothiazolinone and Methylisothiazolinone, which are used as preservatives.